Posted on

Rolling Stone: “Unique and unforgettable”

Rolling Stone Logo

From Rolling Stone:

“Delicate work is being transacted in this unique and unforgettable documentary about two nannies. Producer and director Jyll Johnstone was one of five children in the care of Martha Kneifel, a refugee from prewar Germany who ruled the Johnstone kids with a firm hand. Co-producer Barbara Ettinger, a childhood pal of Johnstone’s in Manhattan, was one of six children who found a soft touch in Ethel Edwards, a nanny from a sharecropping family in the rural South. Johnstone, an actress, and Ettinger, a photographer, wanted to film a tribute to the two nannies (Martha died in October) who played such an integral part in their formative years.

They did a lot more. What could have been a mere memoir becomes a provocative document about the changing nature of family. Johnstone and Ettinger were children of ’40s privilege; today, child care is often a necessity. Through Martha and Ethel and those whose lives they’ve touched, the filmmakers catch the emotional highs and lows of surrogate parenting and craft a touching film of harsh, haunting truth.”

Martha And Ethel Rolling Stone

Related Press


Vanity Fair Features Filmmakers Jyll Johnstone and Barbara Ettinger

“Johnstone and Ettinger have created a filmic reflection on their own nanny-controlled youth, called Martha & Ethel, a paean to…

Read More

Critic’s Notebook; Sundance: Some Surprises Amid the Frivolity

From the New York Times: “One of the most revealing, eloquent and well-received films at the festival, a documentary about…

Read More